Spanking remains a common, if controversial, childrearing practice in the united states in this article, i pair mounting research indicating that spanking is both ineffective and harmful with professional and human rights opinions disavowing the practice i conclude that spanking is a form of. What follows is a list of common failed arguments in favor of parental spanking of children followed by brief responses spanking has been done for generations, it is a well-accepted part of the culture, and most households use the practice. An argument against spanking, a common method of discipline pages 2 words 861 view full essay more essays like this: argument against spanking, common method, discipline not sure what i'd do without @kibin - alfredo alvarez, student @ miami university argument against spanking, common method, discipline not sure what i'd do without @kibin. Spanking (one of the most common methods of physical punishment) slapping, pinching, or pulling hitting with an object, such as a paddle, belt, hairbrush, whip, or stick.
If you think that spanking is the issue what about the hundreds of kids at school that are complete idiots because there was not consistent discipline of any kind taught by discipline that works. Children deserve parents who vow not to let corporal punishment become an established method of discipline and who are willing to learn how to model patience, caring, kindness, and reason to help them grow to become all that they are capable of. Transcript of spanking - yes or no spanking - yes or no what is spanking survey said field work results spanking is detrimental argument against spanking leads to aggressive behavior affects parent/child relationship 100% said spanking 625% said abuse open hand buttocks/extremities intent to discipline without physical harm.
Common methods include spanking or paddling campaigns against corporal punishment have aimed to bring about legal reform to ban the use of corporal punishment against minors in homes and schools an argument that flogging might be better than jail time. There are four broad points to consider: (1) spanking is the historical norm, (2) context matters, (3) most of the so called evidence that spanking is harmful is not really evidence at all, and (4) emotional outrage at what people now call child abuse does not an argument against spanking make. Little is said about spanking5 even today several popular the necessity of parental discipline is a common topic in goes without saying that this paradoxical language cannot be used as an argument for the corporal punishment of children16 it is interesting that none of the other passages noted by clifford has any type of paradoxical.
In an online editorial, the editors of christianity today have gone on the record against spanking the subtitle of the article says that “misuse of biblical teaching on discipline can have deadly consequences” the editors then go on to list several instances of fatal child abuse that have been linked to parents who take a literal interpretation of scriptural passages on discipline. Arguments against spanking edit anti-spanking advocates argue chiefly that spanking is abusive, that it is ineffective, and that it teaches children that physical violence is an acceptable way to deal with other people. General statements against corporal punishment psychologist h stephen glenn said corporal punishment is the least effective method [of discipline] punishment reinforces a failure identity punishment reinforces a failure identity. 18 important facts about spanking non-violent discipline methods to try, what’s the harm in teaching love over anger the argument that parents use spanking in a calm, controlled, and.
Spanking used to be a fairly common form of discipline for parents to use on their children, but is now frowned upon by many child rearing experts on the other hand, most adults were spanked as children with little, if any, negative consequences. Let’s talk spanking to spank or not to spank i also use alternative discipline methods (losing privileges, time-outs) and i talk to my kids a lot i turned against spanking before having children when florida, my home, passed a law declaring spanking with anything other than your hand to be abuse, and i could not ever abide the. Arguments against spanking spanking is one of the most common methods of discipline used by parents even though the very same parents do not condone hitting people, they believe that spanking is a quick and effective method for exterminating unwanted behavior or encouraging desired behavior (ramsburg 1.
Spanking of children in today’s society, there is a fine line between spanking your children being a normal disciplinary action why spanking is an effective form of punishment for children they need to be discipline all parents know children need limits and boundaries. The case against spanking physical discipline is slowly declining as some studies reveal lasting harms for children by brendan l smith april 2012, vol 43, no 4 a public education campaign on “the effectiveness and outcomes associated with corporal punishment and nonphysical methods of discipline,” the proposed resolution states.
There is a classic story about the mother who believed in spanking as a necessary part of discipline until one day she observed her three- year-old daughter hitting her one-year-old son. I would concede the authors' point that most (certainly many) of the arguments against spanking could also be leveled against non-physical forms of discipline, which may be used very injudiciously to the detriment of a child's development. Corporal punishment in schools is an emotive and controversial topic for many people the arguments for and against mainly revolve around the ethics and practicalities of using it as a way of maintaining student discipline.